- Equity Research Cheat Sheets
- Posts
- AAL 3Q25 - Solid Q. What's next? Bull case $20. Bear case $8.
AAL 3Q25 - Solid Q. What's next? Bull case $20. Bear case $8.
Cheat Sheets
AMERICAN AIRLINES GROUP INC. (AAL)
📊 Record Q3 Revenue $13.7B (+0.3% YoY) | Loss -$0.17 EPS (High End of Guidance) | Corporate Revenue +14% YoY | AAdvantage +7% YoY | Co-Brand Spending +9% | New CCO Nat Pieper
Premium Lie-Flat Seats +50% by 2030 | Citi Partnership $10B Remuneration Target (~2030) = $1.5B Incremental Operating Income vs 2024 | Chicago AAdvantage +20% YoY | Premium Seats Growing 2x Main Cabin Rate
💰 Market Cap: $8.0B | 🏢 137K Employees | 🌍 350+ Destinations, 60+ Countries
👨💼 CEO Robert Isom | 🎯 Oneworld Alliance Member | 🇺🇸 Fort Worth, TX
$12.17
📈 +$0.50 (+4.28%) After Earnings
-36% YTD | Q3 2025 Post-Earnings Rally
Price Targets (12-18 Months)
Current Price: $12.17 (After Hours)
$20.00
Bull Case (+64%)
2027 EPS: $3.50 | P/E: 5.7x
Revenue Recovery & Debt Paydown
🚀 Needs:
Citi deal hits $10B target (~2030) = $1.5B extra profit • Premium seats grow 2x faster than main cabin • Corporate revenue sustains +14% growth • Hub expansion (NY/Chicago/Phoenix/Miami/Philly) wins share • DFW becomes world's largest single carrier hub • Indirect revenue grows past restoration levels • New CCO executes (25+ yrs experience) • AAdvantage accelerates (Chicago +20% shows potential) • Free WiFi drives loyalty (largest fleet + AT&T deal) • Flagship lounges expand brand premium positioning$14.00
Base Case (+15%)
2027 EPS: $2.00 | P/E: 7.0x
Steady Execution
⚖️ Needs:
Indirect revenue restored by end 2025, grows in 2026 • Corporate revenue momentum continues (+14% pace) • Premium cabin outperforms via AAdvantage loyalty • Citi partnership launches Jan 1 with Globe card • Hub growth: NY/Chicago → add Phoenix/Miami/Philly 2026 • Flagship Suite expands to 777/A321XLR fleets • Free WiFi (AT&T) boosts engagement • DFW Terminal F completes on schedule • Debt hits <$35B by 2027 with $1B+ FCF • CASM-ex stays 2-4% range • New CCO transition smooth$8.00
Bear Case (-34%)
2027 EPS: $0.50 | P/E: 16.0x
Demand Collapse
⚠️ Risk:
Domestic demand craters (load factor -1.6% worsens) • Premium fades as business travel stays weak • Indirect revenue stalls at restoration, no growth • International yields collapse on overcapacity • Fuel prices surge from $2.37/gal • Labor costs explode (+8.9% YoY unsustainable) • Industry capacity war kills pricing • Recession crushes travel demand • $36.8B debt + rising rates = FCF turns negative • Delta/United win premium share • Q4 miss drops full year below $0.65The TL;DR
💰
What Happened
LOSS: -$139M (-$0.17 EPS) at HIGH END of guidance - revenue beat expectations
CORPORATE SURGE: Corporate revenue +14% YoY - sales strategy working
2026 UPSIDE: CEO: "considerable upside into 2026" with revenue opportunity
PREMIUM WIN: Premium outperforming main cabin via AAdvantage loyalty
SEPTEMBER TURN: Unit revenue positive YoY - inflection confirmed
CORPORATE SURGE: Corporate revenue +14% YoY - sales strategy working
2026 UPSIDE: CEO: "considerable upside into 2026" with revenue opportunity
PREMIUM WIN: Premium outperforming main cabin via AAdvantage loyalty
SEPTEMBER TURN: Unit revenue positive YoY - inflection confirmed
📈
Why It Matters
INFLECTION: September positive = trend reversing after quarters of pain
RESTORATION DONE: Indirect revenue fixed by year-end, growth mode 2026
LOYALTY POWER: AAdvantage +7% (Chicago +20%), co-brand +9%
CITI SCALE: $10B target (~2030) = $1.5B profit boost vs 2024
PREMIUM SHIFT: Lie-flat +50% by 2030, growing 2x main cabin rate
RESTORATION DONE: Indirect revenue fixed by year-end, growth mode 2026
LOYALTY POWER: AAdvantage +7% (Chicago +20%), co-brand +9%
CITI SCALE: $10B target (~2030) = $1.5B profit boost vs 2024
PREMIUM SHIFT: Lie-flat +50% by 2030, growing 2x main cabin rate
🎯
Management Strategy
NEW CCO: Nat Pieper (25+ yrs Delta/Alaska) joins Nov 3
HUB POWER: 8 of 10 largest US metros - best positioning
2026 GROWTH: NY/Chicago/Phoenix/Miami/Philly - no new gates needed
DFW MEGA HUB: Terminal F = world's largest single carrier hub
CX FOCUS: "Value multiplier" - infinite improvements pipeline
HUB POWER: 8 of 10 largest US metros - best positioning
2026 GROWTH: NY/Chicago/Phoenix/Miami/Philly - no new gates needed
DFW MEGA HUB: Terminal F = world's largest single carrier hub
CX FOCUS: "Value multiplier" - infinite improvements pipeline
⚠️
Key Concerns
3 STRAIGHT LOSSES: Q3 loss despite "record revenue" - margins broken
COST SURGE: CASM +3.9%, wages +8.9% while yields drop -2.0%
DEBT WALL: $36.8B total, $29.9B net - highest leverage vs peers
DOMESTIC WEAK: Load factor down, PRASM -1.6%, yields -1.0%
GDP RISK: CFO admits "dependent on economy" = recession vulnerable
COST SURGE: CASM +3.9%, wages +8.9% while yields drop -2.0%
DEBT WALL: $36.8B total, $29.9B net - highest leverage vs peers
DOMESTIC WEAK: Load factor down, PRASM -1.6%, yields -1.0%
GDP RISK: CFO admits "dependent on economy" = recession vulnerable
🐂 Bull Thesis
💰
Citi Partnership Goldmine
$10B TARGET: Co-brand hits $10B annually by ~2030
$1.5B PROFIT: Incremental operating income vs 2024 at scale
JAN 1 LAUNCH: Exclusive Citi deal starts, in-flight already cutover
CARD GROWTH: Spending +9% YoY, new Globe card launched
CHICAGO +20%: AAdvantage surge shows systemwide potential
PREMIUM DRIVER: Members = higher yield + premium demand
$1.5B PROFIT: Incremental operating income vs 2024 at scale
JAN 1 LAUNCH: Exclusive Citi deal starts, in-flight already cutover
CARD GROWTH: Spending +9% YoY, new Globe card launched
CHICAGO +20%: AAdvantage surge shows systemwide potential
PREMIUM DRIVER: Members = higher yield + premium demand
📈
Revenue Restoration → Growth
DONE 2025: "Fully recovered revenue share" by year-end
GROWTH 2026: "Shift to growing share beyond historical levels"
CORPORATE +14%: Q3 surge confirms strategy working
SEPT TURN: Unit revenue positive = momentum building
SALES TEAM: Building org, using loyalty to win customers
DISTRIBUTION: Improved capabilities = "significant value"
GROWTH 2026: "Shift to growing share beyond historical levels"
CORPORATE +14%: Q3 surge confirms strategy working
SEPT TURN: Unit revenue positive = momentum building
SALES TEAM: Building org, using loyalty to win customers
DISTRIBUTION: Improved capabilities = "significant value"
✈️
Premium Product Transformation
FLAGSHIP SUITE: 787-9 led satisfaction Q3, rolling to A321XLR + 777s
LIE-FLAT +50%: Massive premium capacity by 2030
2X GROWTH: Premium seats grow 2x faster than main cabin
DFW MEGA HUB: World's largest single carrier hub coming
LOUNGES: New Flagship (Miami/Charlotte) + Admiral's Clubs
FREE WIFI: AT&T deal, free Jan 1 - more aircraft than any airline
LIE-FLAT +50%: Massive premium capacity by 2030
2X GROWTH: Premium seats grow 2x faster than main cabin
DFW MEGA HUB: World's largest single carrier hub coming
LOUNGES: New Flagship (Miami/Charlotte) + Admiral's Clubs
FREE WIFI: AT&T deal, free Jan 1 - more aircraft than any airline
🎯
Hub Network Advantage
8 OF 10: Largest US metros - best positioning vs peers
2026 SCALE: NY/Chicago/Phoenix/Miami/Philly growth coming
NO CAPEX: Phoenix/Philly use existing gates - free growth
DFW/CLT: Restored fast post-pandemic, DFW stays #1
NEW CCO: Nat Pieper 25+ yrs experience proven executor
BALANCED: Guardrails on supply/demand vs competitors
2026 SCALE: NY/Chicago/Phoenix/Miami/Philly growth coming
NO CAPEX: Phoenix/Philly use existing gates - free growth
DFW/CLT: Restored fast post-pandemic, DFW stays #1
NEW CCO: Nat Pieper 25+ yrs experience proven executor
BALANCED: Guardrails on supply/demand vs competitors
🐻 Bear Thesis
📉
Three Straight Quarterly Losses
PROFIT FAIL: Q3 loss despite "record revenue" - broken model
Q2 WEAK: Barely profitable vs year ago despite records
PEER GAP: Delta ~10% margin, United ~8%, AAL only 1.1%
COST SURGE: CASM +3.9% while yields drop -2.0% = squeeze
GUIDE DOWN: Full year $0.65-$0.95 lowered - execution failing
Q2 WEAK: Barely profitable vs year ago despite records
PEER GAP: Delta ~10% margin, United ~8%, AAL only 1.1%
COST SURGE: CASM +3.9% while yields drop -2.0% = squeeze
GUIDE DOWN: Full year $0.65-$0.95 lowered - execution failing
💸
Domestic Demand Deterioration
YIELD DROP: Domestic 19.94¢ vs 20.14¢ (-1.0%), PRASM -1.6%
LOAD FACTOR: 85.6% vs 86.1% prior year = weaker demand
REVENUE FLAT: $8.7B unchanged YoY despite capacity up
MISMATCH: ASM +2.1% but revenue only +0.5% = oversupply
SEPT FRAGILE: One good month doesn't make a trend
LOAD FACTOR: 85.6% vs 86.1% prior year = weaker demand
REVENUE FLAT: $8.7B unchanged YoY despite capacity up
MISMATCH: ASM +2.1% but revenue only +0.5% = oversupply
SEPT FRAGILE: One good month doesn't make a trend
💰
Debt Burden & Cost Inflation
MASSIVE DEBT: $36.8B total, $29.9B net - worst leverage of big 3
INTEREST PAIN: $432M Q3, -$1.3B YTD eats FCF
SLOW PAYDOWN: $35B target 2027 only $1.8B reduction - too slow
LABOR SURGE: Wages +8.9% YoY unsustainable vs flat revenue
REGIONAL COSTS: Up +8.6% YoY - no discipline
FCF TRAPPED: $1.7B YTD but debt service leaves little for growth
INTEREST PAIN: $432M Q3, -$1.3B YTD eats FCF
SLOW PAYDOWN: $35B target 2027 only $1.8B reduction - too slow
LABOR SURGE: Wages +8.9% YoY unsustainable vs flat revenue
REGIONAL COSTS: Up +8.6% YoY - no discipline
FCF TRAPPED: $1.7B YTD but debt service leaves little for growth
⏰
Competitive Disadvantage Persists
MARGIN GAP: 1.1% vs Delta 10%+, United 8%+ - structural problem
STRATEGY FAIL: Indirect revenue "restoration" = 2024 self-inflicted wound
LEADERSHIP CHURN: New CCO (4th change) - execution risk
CAPEX LIMITED: Debt restricts fleet vs better-funded rivals
PREMIUM LAG: Behind Delta on revenue per departure despite focus
HUB SPRAWL: 8 hubs less efficient than Delta fortress model
GDP RISK: CFO admits economic dependence = recession exposed
STRATEGY FAIL: Indirect revenue "restoration" = 2024 self-inflicted wound
LEADERSHIP CHURN: New CCO (4th change) - execution risk
CAPEX LIMITED: Debt restricts fleet vs better-funded rivals
PREMIUM LAG: Behind Delta on revenue per departure despite focus
HUB SPRAWL: 8 hubs less efficient than Delta fortress model
GDP RISK: CFO admits economic dependence = recession exposed
This analysis is for informational purposes only and should not be considered investment advice. Please consult with a financial advisor before making investment decisions.
