- Equity Research Cheat Sheets
- Posts
- MMM 3Q25 - Paper chase. Bull case $200. Bear case $130.
MMM 3Q25 - Paper chase. Bull case $200. Bear case $130.
Cheat Sheets
3M COMPANY (MMM)
π 4th Straight Quarter All Groups Growing | EPS $2.19 (Beat) | Revenue $6.5B (+3.2%) | OTIF 91.6% (20-Yr High) | Innovation Exploding
New Products +70% | Cross-Sell $100M Pipeline | OEE 63% (+300bps) | Cost of Quality 5.7% (-150bps) | FCF 111% | Guidance Raised
π° Market Cap: $88.0B | π’ 61,500 Employees | π 70+ Countries
π¨βπΌ CEO William Brown | π― 3 Business Groups | πΊπΈ St. Paul, MN
$163.71
π +$8.93 (+5.77%) Today
+35% YTD | -0.3% from 52-wk High
Price Targets (12-18 Months)
Current Price: $163.71
$200.00
Bull Case (+22%)
Operational Excellence
π Needs:
Organic growth accelerates to 4-5% β’ Operating margins reach 26%+ β’ PFAS settlements finalized with no surprises β’ Innovation pipeline delivers β’ All 3 segments firing β’ Portfolio optimization complete β’ Electronics recovery accelerates
$180.00
Base Case (+10%)
Steady Progress
βοΈ Needs:
2-3% organic growth sustained β’ Margin expansion 150-200bps annually β’ 3M eXcellence model execution continues β’ Consumer stabilizes β’ EPS grows 8-12% β’ PFAS risk contained β’ Free cash flow conversion >100%
$130.00
Bear Case (-21%)
PFAS Explosion
β οΈ Risk:
PFAS liabilities balloon beyond $10B β’ Industrial recession hits demand β’ Tariffs crush margins β’ Electronics segment worsens β’ Consumer weakness persists β’ Innovation pipeline disappoints β’ Restructuring costs escalate β’ Multiple compresses to 15x
The TL;DR
π° What Happened
β’ Q3 EPS: $2.19 adjusted BEAT (vs $2.07 est) - +10% YoY growth, FCF conversion 111%
β’ Revenue: $6.5B (+3.2% organic) - FOURTH consecutive quarter positive organic growth across ALL 3 groups
β’ Margins: 24.7% operating margin (+170bps YoY) - excellence model + operational rigor driving results
β’ Innovation EXPLODING: 70 new products in Q3, 196 YTD (+70% vs prior year), tracking >250 for full year vs 215 goal
β’ New Product Revenue: Up 30% in Q3 from products launched in last 5 years, tracking high teens FY growth
β’ OTIF 91.6% - Improved 200bps sequentially, 300bps YoY, HIGHEST in 20+ years, 4 months straight >90%
β’ 2025 Guidance: RAISED to $7.95-$8.05 EPS from $7.75-$8.00, organic growth >2%, FCF conversion >100%
β’ Revenue: $6.5B (+3.2% organic) - FOURTH consecutive quarter positive organic growth across ALL 3 groups
β’ Margins: 24.7% operating margin (+170bps YoY) - excellence model + operational rigor driving results
β’ Innovation EXPLODING: 70 new products in Q3, 196 YTD (+70% vs prior year), tracking >250 for full year vs 215 goal
β’ New Product Revenue: Up 30% in Q3 from products launched in last 5 years, tracking high teens FY growth
β’ OTIF 91.6% - Improved 200bps sequentially, 300bps YoY, HIGHEST in 20+ years, 4 months straight >90%
β’ 2025 Guidance: RAISED to $7.95-$8.05 EPS from $7.75-$8.00, organic growth >2%, FCF conversion >100%
β
Bull Case
β’ Excellence Model WORKING: 4 straight quarters organic growth across ALL segments = operational rigor delivering
β’ Cross-selling EXPLODING: $100M+ pipeline (doubled since Q2), already closed $30M annualized = exceeding Investor Day targets
β’ OTIF beast: 91.6% (highest in 20+ years), up 300bps YoY, sustaining >90% for 4 months = customer loyalty unlocked
β’ Innovation velocity: 70 products launched Q3 (+70% YoY), tracking >250 FY vs 215 goal = pipeline accelerating
β’ New product $ impact: Revenue from last 5 years' products up 30% Q3, high teens FY = innovation monetizing
β’ OEE gains: 63% YTD (+300bps YoY) on 229 assets (60% volume) = capacity unlocking, example: optical adhesives 63%β81% freed capacity to DOUBLE customer share
β’ Cross-selling EXPLODING: $100M+ pipeline (doubled since Q2), already closed $30M annualized = exceeding Investor Day targets
β’ OTIF beast: 91.6% (highest in 20+ years), up 300bps YoY, sustaining >90% for 4 months = customer loyalty unlocked
β’ Innovation velocity: 70 products launched Q3 (+70% YoY), tracking >250 FY vs 215 goal = pipeline accelerating
β’ New product $ impact: Revenue from last 5 years' products up 30% Q3, high teens FY = innovation monetizing
β’ OEE gains: 63% YTD (+300bps YoY) on 229 assets (60% volume) = capacity unlocking, example: optical adhesives 63%β81% freed capacity to DOUBLE customer share
β Bear Case
β’ Growth still modest: 3.2% organic = solid but not spectacular, needs sustained acceleration to re-rate valuation
β’ Macro remains soft: CEO said "macro trends remain soft and largely unchanged from Q2" = no tailwinds helping
β’ Roofing granules weak: "Surprisingly weak roofing granules market" per CEO = cyclical exposure biting
β’ Auto headwinds: Auto OE improving "modestly" but commercial vehicles weakening = mixed picture
β’ Consumer flat: CBG flat as expected, no growth inflection yet despite new products = challenged segment
β’ Quality still work: Cost of poor quality 5.7% (down 150bps YoY) but target <4% = long runway, execution risk remains
β’ Macro remains soft: CEO said "macro trends remain soft and largely unchanged from Q2" = no tailwinds helping
β’ Roofing granules weak: "Surprisingly weak roofing granules market" per CEO = cyclical exposure biting
β’ Auto headwinds: Auto OE improving "modestly" but commercial vehicles weakening = mixed picture
β’ Consumer flat: CBG flat as expected, no growth inflection yet despite new products = challenged segment
β’ Quality still work: Cost of poor quality 5.7% (down 150bps YoY) but target <4% = long runway, execution risk remains
π Bull Thesis
π
3M eXcellence Model = Real
Proof Points: FOUR consecutive quarters organic growth across all segments, unprecedented consistency
Commercial Excellence: Cross-selling pipeline $100M+ (doubled since Q2), closed $30M annualized, expanding TBGβSIBGβCBG
Sales Rigor: "Squarely focused on accounts with highest potential while limiting special pricing actions" - CEO
Predictive Analytics: Leveraging AI to win back business lost or at risk, reducing churn systematically
Commercial Excellence: Cross-selling pipeline $100M+ (doubled since Q2), closed $30M annualized, expanding TBGβSIBGβCBG
Sales Rigor: "Squarely focused on accounts with highest potential while limiting special pricing actions" - CEO
Predictive Analytics: Leveraging AI to win back business lost or at risk, reducing churn systematically
π
Margin Expansion Machine
Operating Leverage: 24.7% operating margin (+170bps YoY), pricing power maintained despite soft macro
OTIF Excellence: 91.6% (highest in 20+ years), saving on service fines, winning shelf space, driving loyalty
Quality Gains: Cost of poor quality 5.7% (down 150bps YoY, -40bps sequentially), target <4% = multi-year runway
Asset Optimization: OEE 63% (+300bps YoY), reducing changeover, unplanned downtime, unlocking volume capacity
OTIF Excellence: 91.6% (highest in 20+ years), saving on service fines, winning shelf space, driving loyalty
Quality Gains: Cost of poor quality 5.7% (down 150bps YoY, -40bps sequentially), target <4% = multi-year runway
Asset Optimization: OEE 63% (+300bps YoY), reducing changeover, unplanned downtime, unlocking volume capacity
π°
Free Cash Flow Returns
Q3 Performance: $1.3B adjusted FCF, 111% conversion = cash generation engine back on track
Capital Returned: $900M Q3 ($400M dividends, $500M buybacks), $3.9B YTD to shareholders
Full Year: Adjusted FCF conversion >100% guidance maintained = predictable cash machine
Portfolio Actions: Sold precision grinding business (<1% sales), 2-3% revenue under review = capital redeployment
Capital Returned: $900M Q3 ($400M dividends, $500M buybacks), $3.9B YTD to shareholders
Full Year: Adjusted FCF conversion >100% guidance maintained = predictable cash machine
Portfolio Actions: Sold precision grinding business (<1% sales), 2-3% revenue under review = capital redeployment
π―
Simplified Portfolio Power
Innovation Acceleration: 196 products launched YTD (+70% vs prior year), tracking >250 FY vs 215 goal, >1,000 by 2027
Examples Working: Scotch-Blue Pro Sharp (regaining share, high single-digit growth), Filtrete size expansion (high single-digit Q3), lightweight SCBA (high teens growth)
Revenue Impact: Sales from products launched in last 5 years up 30% Q3, high teens FY = innovation monetizing
SIBG Turnaround: 11 quarters organic growth journey: -6% (early 2023) β +4.1% (Q3 2025), new products doubled, OTIF +12pts
Examples Working: Scotch-Blue Pro Sharp (regaining share, high single-digit growth), Filtrete size expansion (high single-digit Q3), lightweight SCBA (high teens growth)
Revenue Impact: Sales from products launched in last 5 years up 30% Q3, high teens FY = innovation monetizing
SIBG Turnaround: 11 quarters organic growth journey: -6% (early 2023) β +4.1% (Q3 2025), new products doubled, OTIF +12pts
π» Bear Thesis
β οΈ
PFAS = Unlimited Liability
The Numbers: $10.3B public water settlement done, but states lining up for more
Scope: 25,000+ products touched PFAS over decades = exposure is MASSIVE
Unknowns: Health effects still emerging, regulatory landscape tightening = future claims unpredictable
Death by 1000 Cuts: Each state settlement chips away at value, overhang never ends
Scope: 25,000+ products touched PFAS over decades = exposure is MASSIVE
Unknowns: Health effects still emerging, regulatory landscape tightening = future claims unpredictable
Death by 1000 Cuts: Each state settlement chips away at value, overhang never ends
π
Growth Still Anemic
The Reality: 3.2% Q3 organic (accelerated from 1.5% H1), but still modest absolute level vs peers
Geography Mix: China high single-digit (share gains), U.S. ~4% (vs 1% H1), Europe returned to growth = improvement but mixed
Daily Orders: +3% YoY across all groups = forward momentum but not explosive
Innovation Lag Closing: New product revenue up 30% Q3, but "early innings" per CEO = monetization just starting
Geography Mix: China high single-digit (share gains), U.S. ~4% (vs 1% H1), Europe returned to growth = improvement but mixed
Daily Orders: +3% YoY across all groups = forward momentum but not explosive
Innovation Lag Closing: New product revenue up 30% Q3, but "early innings" per CEO = monetization just starting
π₯
Cyclical Headwinds Building
Roofing Weakness: CEO cited "surprisingly weak roofing granules market" = housing slowdown biting
Auto Mixed: Auto OE improving "modestly," commercial vehicles weakening = uneven recovery
Consumer Flat: CBG flat as expected despite new product launches = no inflection yet
Macro Backdrop: CEO: "Macro trends remain soft and largely unchanged from Q2" = no external help coming
Auto Mixed: Auto OE improving "modestly," commercial vehicles weakening = uneven recovery
Consumer Flat: CBG flat as expected despite new product launches = no inflection yet
Macro Backdrop: CEO: "Macro trends remain soft and largely unchanged from Q2" = no external help coming
π
Valuation Has No Cushion
The Math: 21x P/E on $8 EPS = no margin of safety for a 3% grower
Conglomerate Discount: Should trade 15-17x like HON, not at premium multiples
Downside Risk: Any PFAS surprise, growth miss, or margin pressure = -20% instantly
Opportunity Cost: Capital tied up in litigation story when cleaner industrial names exist
Conglomerate Discount: Should trade 15-17x like HON, not at premium multiples
Downside Risk: Any PFAS surprise, growth miss, or margin pressure = -20% instantly
Opportunity Cost: Capital tied up in litigation story when cleaner industrial names exist
This analysis is for informational purposes only and should not be considered investment advice. Please consult with a financial advisor before making investment decisions.

