PAYX F1Q26 - Who wins - strong earnings or stagnant macro?

Cheat Sheets presented by stocktwits

September 30, 2025

Paychex Investment Report - Q2 FY2025 HR & Payroll Leadership

PAYCHEX (PAYX)

💼🏢 HR & Payroll Market Leader | Paychex Flex Platform Pioneer

Q1 FY2026 Results | $1.5B Q1 Revenue, +17% YoY, Paycor Integration Ahead of Plan

💰 Market Cap: $52.1B | 🏢 Employees: 19,000+ | 👥 Clients: 800K+
👨‍💼 CEO John Gibson | 💻 Paychex Flex Platform | 🎯 Paycor Integration
$123.22
📉 -$5.31 (-4.13%) Today
Current Price
Price Target Scenarios

18-Month Horizon (2026 Targets)

$165.00
Bull Case (+34%)
HCM Dominance
Paycor Synergy Leader
📊 Valuation Calculation:
• 2026E EPS: $5.75 × P/E: 28.7x = $165.00
🚀 Key Assumptions:
Paycor integration exceeds $100M synergy targets • PEO growth accelerates to 10%+ • AI-driven efficiency gains expand margins to 44% • Small business formation surge • Mid-market penetration deepens • Cross-selling opportunities maximize
$150.00
Base Case (+22%)
Steady Growth
Market Leader
📊 Valuation Calculation:
• 2026E EPS: $5.46 × P/E: 27.5x = $150.00
⚖️ Key Assumptions:
Consistent 8-10% earnings growth • Paycor delivers $90M cost synergies • Client retention remains strong • Margins expand to 43% • PEO grows 7-9% as guided • Labor market stabilizes
$105.00
Bear Case (-15%)
Economic Downturn
Integration Challenges
📊 Valuation Calculation:
• 2026E EPS: $5.00 × P/E: 21.0x = $105.00
🔻 Key Assumptions:
Economic recession impacts small businesses • Paycor integration delays and costs • Client churn increases • Employment levels decline • Competitive pricing pressure • Interest rate headwinds persist • Florida PEO challenges worsen
Bottom Line for Retail Investors
👑
Market Leadership
Leading HCM provider with 800K+ clients, pays 1 in 12 private sector workers, 50+ years proven track record, industry-leading 401(k) integration
🤖
Technology Innovation
Paychex Flex all-in-one platform, AI-powered recruiting copilot, advanced analytics, seamless integrations, modern cloud-based infrastructure
📈
Growth Catalyst
Paycor acquisition driving 16-18% revenue growth FY26, $90M cost synergies, cross-selling opportunities, PEO gaining market share
⚠️
Risk Factors
Economic sensitivity to employment levels, Paycor integration execution risk, competitive HCM market, interest rate dependency, valuation concerns

📊 Q1 FY2026 "Robust Growth & Integration Excellence" Performance

$1.5B Q1 Revenue, +17% YoY, 35.2% Operating Margin, Adj. EPS +5%, Paycor Integration Exceeding Expectations

💵
$1.5B
Q1 FY2026 Revenue
+17% YoY
📊
$1.22
Q1 Adj. Diluted EPS
+5% vs $1.16 Prior
📈
40.7%
Q1 Adj. Operating Margin
15% Adj. Op. Income Growth
💰
$549M
Q1 Shareholder Returns
Dividends + Buybacks

📞 Key Q1 FY2026 Earnings Highlights

🎯
Paycor Integration Excellence
On track to exceed $90M cost synergy target, back-end tech integrations completed, revenue synergies building strong pipeline, largest ASO deal in company history closed to Paycor client
💼
Management Solutions Surge
$1.2B revenue (+21%), Paycor contributed ~17% to growth, price realization and product penetration driving per-client revenue, 50K Paycor clients targeted for cross-sell
🏢
PEO Record Performance
$329M revenue (+3%), record retention levels continue, mid-single digit worksite employee growth, double-digit bookings growth, leading the PEO market
🤖
AI Innovation Scaling
AI Insights expanded to all HCM clients, generative AI HR guidance tool launched using 40M+ annual client interactions, agentic AI pilots automating high-volume tasks

📍 CEO Commentary: "We are off to a strong start in fiscal year 26, delivering robust 17% revenue growth and solid adjusted diluted earnings per share growth of 5%" - John Gibson

🎯 Paycor Cross-Sell Success: More than half of 50K Paycor clients in sweet spot for ASO and PEO, propensity model developed to target most likely buyers, landed one of largest ASO deals in company history with multi-thousand employee Paycor client

🤝 Partner Plus Momentum: Broker enrollment nearly doubled since June, new CPA partner portal launched, Bill.com partnership for AP/AR announced with 7M payer network, strengthening referral channels

🔮 FY2026 Raised Guidance: Total revenue growth 16.5-18% maintained, adjusted EPS growth raised to 9-11% (from 8.5-10.5%), Q2 revenue expected +18% with 41% adjusted operating margin, 40% ROE maintained

🚀 Why PAYX Bulls Are Right
👑
Unmatched Market Position
Industry-leading HCM provider with 800K+ clients, 50+ year track record, pays 1 in 12 private sector workers, record client retention at pre-pandemic levels, comprehensive value proposition
🎯
Paycor Synergies Exceeding Expectations
Integration ahead of plan, $90M cost synergies on track with additional opportunities identified, 50K Paycor clients targeted for cross-sell, upmarket ASO opportunity larger than anticipated
🤖
AI-Driven Differentiation
Leveraging 40M+ annual client interactions for AI training, agentic AI pilots automating routine tasks, generative AI tools enhancing productivity across organization, data moat advantage
💰
Financial Strength & Partner Momentum
40% ROE maintained, $1.7B cash position, Partner Plus broker enrollment doubled, new CPA portal launched, Bill.com partnership adds payment capabilities to platform
🐻 Why PAYX Bears Have Valid Concerns
📉
Small Business Sensitivity
Revenue tied to employment levels and wage growth, elevated bankruptcies continuing from Q4, concentrated losses in small business segment, micro segment showed weakness in Q4
🎯
Integration Execution Risk
Paycor segmentation complexity creates reporting challenges, cultural integration ongoing, employee attrition risks, revenue synergy realization uncertain, investment needs may offset synergies
🏥
Florida PEO Headwinds Persist
At-risk medical plan enrollment challenges continue, competitive Florida market pressuring growth, worker's comp rate pressures on agency side, health plan costs rising impacting participation
💸
Interest Rate & Macro Uncertainty
Fed rate cuts create headwind on float income, government shutdown risks, H-1B visa uncertainty, organic growth only ~4-5%, expense growth pressures from integration investments

This analysis is for informational purposes only and should not be considered investment advice. Please consult with a financial advisor before making investment decisions.